Top Flite Giant Scale Spitfire ARF
#77
My Feedback: (1)
RE: Top Flite Giant Scale Spitfire ARF
+1 and some for Chad....
He knows more about the Spitfire than probably all of us here. I didn't see him ranting at all. I never have. Oh, and before you tell someone to go buy a balsa farm and design their own plane, you might want to know who you're talking too....you see, thats exactly what he does. So lets just keep our snide remarks to ourselves about what he can do eh?
Casey
#78
My Feedback: (43)
RE: Top Flite Giant Scale Spitfire ARF
I'm with Chad on this. I never said that I expected dead nuts scale for pennies. It does not cost one dollar more to put the correct dihedral in the plans that they send to china. I know this is a sport scale plane but when the plane is sitting on the flight line and the wings appear to be sagging in the heat due to the lack of dihedreal, it causes me to not buy it.
#79
My Feedback: (243)
RE: Top Flite Giant Scale Spitfire ARF
ORIGINAL: tp777fo
I am amazed at the guys who want a scale masters arf for $49. If you want a real scale model then buy some plans, a balsa plantation an start whittling. Until then just be quiet. The TF models are.sport scale..it kinda looks like one and flies great. If you don't like them don't buy one....stop plugging up the threads with the mindless rants.
I am amazed at the guys who want a scale masters arf for $49. If you want a real scale model then buy some plans, a balsa plantation an start whittling. Until then just be quiet. The TF models are.sport scale..it kinda looks like one and flies great. If you don't like them don't buy one....stop plugging up the threads with the mindless rants.
Too many guys out there want to be catered too by the manufacturers. They give little thought to a product being prepared for successful use by other people who may not have time, skills, facilities or even desire to 'masterscale' their model.
Cowl not shaped right? Not enough dihedral? Covering colors all wrong? All sound like easy things to fix for an experienced modeler.
#80
My Feedback: (60)
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: Litchfield Park,
AZ
Posts: 7,677
Likes: 0
Received 25 Likes
on
23 Posts
RE: Top Flite Giant Scale Spitfire ARF
ORIGINAL: tp777fo
Yep...I'd say it straight to you in person also and then I'd invite you to have a cold beer.
Yep...I'd say it straight to you in person also and then I'd invite you to have a cold beer.
#81
Senior Member
My Feedback: (93)
Join Date: Feb 2002
Location: Mason,
MI
Posts: 874
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Top Flite Giant Scale Spitfire ARF
I'm still with Chad, this forum is a place to openly express your observations and experiences with products that appear in the market and I, for one, value that.
#82
My Feedback: (73)
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Inverness Fl
Posts: 299
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Top Flite Giant Scale Spitfire ARF
Are there any more pics of this plane other than the one on this threds first page. I would like to see exactly how much dihedral the plane has or doesn't have. I understand its a sport scale but the outline to me is very important. Like some of the sport P51s you see with a flat wing. I could not live with that.
#83
RE: Top Flite Giant Scale Spitfire ARF
Now, now...
As someone who has actually had a cold beer (or two...) with TP777fo, I can say that he's not only a great guy to have a beer with.... but a stand-up dude in the truest sense. Chad, these southern guys do get lippy, but I imagine that you two in person would have lots to talk about. Chad's input and modeling expertise is frankly one of the reasons I monitor this particular section of RCU, so his opinions and observations are not only valid, but quite welcome so behave, Tom (and stop fussing over crap-scale Spits and get to work on an F-18)...
As someone who has actually had a cold beer (or two...) with TP777fo, I can say that he's not only a great guy to have a beer with.... but a stand-up dude in the truest sense. Chad, these southern guys do get lippy, but I imagine that you two in person would have lots to talk about. Chad's input and modeling expertise is frankly one of the reasons I monitor this particular section of RCU, so his opinions and observations are not only valid, but quite welcome so behave, Tom (and stop fussing over crap-scale Spits and get to work on an F-18)...
#85
Senior Member
My Feedback: (2)
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: Las Vegas, NV
Posts: 1,266
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Top Flite Giant Scale Spitfire ARF
I hope we don't see one. I am already tired of hearing how bad this model is before it is released. It is a SPORT scale ARF. One I will enjoy. Everybody has the right to comment on the plane, but it get's really old hearing about ever little detail that is wrong with the plane before it is released. Like the GS Corsair ARF. A beautiful plane right out of the box, but a lot of people saying it won't fly safely without modification's. I have no modification's and if flies great.
#86
My Feedback: (3)
RE: Top Flite Giant Scale Spitfire ARF
ORIGINAL: Dick T.
Hey Tom, your comments in the thread are appropriate as far as I am concerned.
Too many guys out there want to be catered too by the manufacturers. They give little thought to a product being prepared for successful use by other people who may not have time, skills, facilities or even desire to 'masterscale' their model.
Cowl not shaped right? Not enough dihedral? Covering colors all wrong? All sound like easy things to fix for an experienced modeler.
ORIGINAL: tp777fo
I am amazed at the guys who want a scale masters arf for $49. If you want a real scale model then buy some plans, a balsa plantation an start whittling. Until then just be quiet. The TF models are.sport scale..it kinda looks like one and flies great. If you don't like them don't buy one....stop plugging up the threads with the mindless rants.
I am amazed at the guys who want a scale masters arf for $49. If you want a real scale model then buy some plans, a balsa plantation an start whittling. Until then just be quiet. The TF models are.sport scale..it kinda looks like one and flies great. If you don't like them don't buy one....stop plugging up the threads with the mindless rants.
Too many guys out there want to be catered too by the manufacturers. They give little thought to a product being prepared for successful use by other people who may not have time, skills, facilities or even desire to 'masterscale' their model.
Cowl not shaped right? Not enough dihedral? Covering colors all wrong? All sound like easy things to fix for an experienced modeler.
This line of reasoning is exactly why the industry keeps doing this to customers. They know you will make up for their deficiencies and call it just part of the hobby. Thats not acceptable. When its a kit you expect all the parts to be there and made correctly and for an ARF its the same thing. As the customer you shouldn't have to correct it, fix it, or modify it because its a finished product. This is the minimum expectation not a luxury and from there you can choose to do what you like.
If the colors are off, the scale dimensions are off, well thats attributed to design decisions, production issues and other factors but bottom line these are scale renditions of aircraft and they are not made to be very accurate. Many times designers use too many references and that is a contributing factor why a model is wrong. They don't understand the subject well enough to tell two Spitfires apart or whatever the case may be or maybe the designer just isn't very good at making a replica of the part. These are matters of personal taste. If the bad looking parts fit together fine then its done well but may look poor.
I just have a long standing problem with people making excuses for model companies and letting them get away with perpetuating poor product development and increasing prices. Say something while you choose to exercise your right not to buy a product or return it and companies will have to listen.
#87
My Feedback: (3)
RE: Top Flite Giant Scale Spitfire ARF
ORIGINAL: Hellcat716
I hope we don't see one. I am already tired of hearing how bad this model is before it is released. It is a SPORT scale ARF. One I will enjoy. Everybody has the right to comment on the plane, but it get's really old hearing about ever little detail that is wrong with the plane before it is released. Like the GS Corsair ARF. A beautiful plane right out of the box, but a lot of people saying it won't fly safely without modification's. I have no modification's and if flies great.
I hope we don't see one. I am already tired of hearing how bad this model is before it is released. It is a SPORT scale ARF. One I will enjoy. Everybody has the right to comment on the plane, but it get's really old hearing about ever little detail that is wrong with the plane before it is released. Like the GS Corsair ARF. A beautiful plane right out of the box, but a lot of people saying it won't fly safely without modification's. I have no modification's and if flies great.
There is every chance this Spit will be fine because so far the FW is doing very well. These are new designs so it seems promising the critical systems are designed well. It does suck to see so much negativity surrounding a new untested product. Good luck TF.
#88
My Feedback: (243)
RE: Top Flite Giant Scale Spitfire ARF
ORIGINAL: Chris Nicastro
Why do I need to fix anything on a new model I paid for?
I just have a long standing problem with people making excuses for model companies and letting them get away with perpetuating poor product development and increasing prices. Say something while you choose to exercise your right not to buy a product or return it and companies will have to listen.
Why do I need to fix anything on a new model I paid for?
I just have a long standing problem with people making excuses for model companies and letting them get away with perpetuating poor product development and increasing prices. Say something while you choose to exercise your right not to buy a product or return it and companies will have to listen.
I should have been clearer by saying:
Cowl not shaped right? Not enough dihedral? Covering colors all wrong? All sound like easy things to fix for an experienced modeler who prefers more accuracy.
TopFlight has a pretty good record at producing stand off scale models that perform well and look good right out of the box. I have done several of their ARF's, warbirds included, and modified some to suit personal taste. Personally I like building but modifying an ARF with good bones can shave off a lot of time and expense.
Personally I can pick apart every Mustang model out there but if the owner is happy with it he doesn't give two squats what I think, and that is the way it should be.
The proposed Spit looks good enough to me. If I want it to be better I will modify it.
#89
My Feedback: (3)
RE: Top Flite Giant Scale Spitfire ARF
Right DT. Were on the same page.
For that reason as well TF should offer all of their GS ARF's as ARC's so the customer can do as they wish. That being said I bet they will reason that sales don't support offering this option. If so were back to the same dilemma, buy an expensive ARF and work on it to your taste, build a kit, or find a full composite ARF that satisfies your needs but costs even more money.
They discontinued all ARC's right?
For that reason as well TF should offer all of their GS ARF's as ARC's so the customer can do as they wish. That being said I bet they will reason that sales don't support offering this option. If so were back to the same dilemma, buy an expensive ARF and work on it to your taste, build a kit, or find a full composite ARF that satisfies your needs but costs even more money.
They discontinued all ARC's right?
#91
My Feedback: (243)
RE: Top Flite Giant Scale Spitfire ARF
It appears the TF Giant Mustang RTC is discontinued but the P-47 is still available. It is my understanding the RTC versions do not sell well in spite of the interest in various forums. To me it shows the interest shown in the forums is actually a very small portion of the market so we are not as influential as some think we are.
Glad I have a couple of the Mustang RTC's in storage for future projects. Picked them up for a song at swap meets as original buyers lost interest. Had an RTC P-47 but traded for the ARF as I like the Tarheel Hal scheme.
Glad I have a couple of the Mustang RTC's in storage for future projects. Picked them up for a song at swap meets as original buyers lost interest. Had an RTC P-47 but traded for the ARF as I like the Tarheel Hal scheme.
#92
My Feedback: (13)
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Johns Island,
SC
Posts: 186
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Top Flite Giant Scale Spitfire ARF
Wow, another ARF and the same handful of people talking about a rivet in the wrong place or the color is off. Talk about beating a dead horse.
Bob H please make it stop!
Bob H please make it stop!
#93
My Feedback: (2)
RE: Top Flite Giant Scale Spitfire ARF
Brian, my dear friend.. Alas one can only do so much in these forums. In fact..I've made a capitulation of sorts and ordered a TF GS Corsair! Shamefull but true.
I may not even trick it up.. well ok just a little.
If this Spit was a Mk Ia or MKV the camo could work. So just pretend its a MKV in North Africa
I may not even trick it up.. well ok just a little.
If this Spit was a Mk Ia or MKV the camo could work. So just pretend its a MKV in North Africa
#95
Senior Member
My Feedback: (8)
RE: Top Flite Giant Scale Spitfire ARF
ORIGINAL: Dick T.
It is my understanding the RTC versions do not sell well in spite of the interest in various forums. To me it shows the interest shown in the forums is actually a very small portion of the market so we are not as influential as some think we are.
It is my understanding the RTC versions do not sell well in spite of the interest in various forums. To me it shows the interest shown in the forums is actually a very small portion of the market so we are not as influential as some think we are.
Dick, you are correct sir. I remember talking with Kangle aircraft years ago and he said his ARC/RTCs sat and sat. There is a very small market for them.
Kelly
#96
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Panama City, PANAMA
Posts: 180
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Top Flite Giant Scale Spitfire ARF
Nice to See TOP FLITE come out with this Bird finally !!! As Top Fligh is know for their high quality. Just a bit disappointed on the Model it would have been nice one of the newer models like the MK XIV
Wondering if this would be as nice as the ESM 50 CC Scale Spitfire..
Wondering if this would be as nice as the ESM 50 CC Scale Spitfire..
#98
My Feedback: (34)
RE: Top Flite Giant Scale Spitfire ARF
Wow what a posting
my CMP Spitfire was my first war bird. I currently built a TopFlite Gaint P40,P51, and P47 this winter.
I was hopeing for a TopFlite Gaint Spitfire but I'll be honest the pic show shows it no mustache looks very plane
I love Top Flite. But the Scale look of my ESM Corsair and new B25 make them look (not as cool)
I was hopeing when they did the Spitfire they were going to do a Super Mairen version or one with more features (supercharger scoop etc)
I will say the Gaint P40 wich is a new ARF than the others seemed way nicer fit and Finnish and the copit was real nice.
I think if this one can be open up for electic like th FW I think it will do ok
my CMP Spitfire was my first war bird. I currently built a TopFlite Gaint P40,P51, and P47 this winter.
I was hopeing for a TopFlite Gaint Spitfire but I'll be honest the pic show shows it no mustache looks very plane
I love Top Flite. But the Scale look of my ESM Corsair and new B25 make them look (not as cool)
I was hopeing when they did the Spitfire they were going to do a Super Mairen version or one with more features (supercharger scoop etc)
I will say the Gaint P40 wich is a new ARF than the others seemed way nicer fit and Finnish and the copit was real nice.
I think if this one can be open up for electic like th FW I think it will do ok
#99
Senior Member
My Feedback: (2)
RE: Top Flite Giant Scale Spitfire ARF
It is understandable way RTC do not sell well. Too small of a market share. Better to get a ARF already covered, stripped the model and recover it the way you want your bird to be. Look at my avatar, that is a H9 .60 size Mustang when they first came out. I stripped the top wing skin covering off and recovered it and spray painted the fuse to get the version that I wanted. Yes it took a lot of extra time - but that is the way it goes sometimes.
#100
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Victoria,
MN
Posts: 3,934
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Top Flite Giant Scale Spitfire ARF
ORIGINAL: Ramstein44
Or maybe this one...
Or maybe this one...
Doing a captured p51 mustang and need some shots of a color side top and bottom...